Questions tagged [discussion]
The question you're asking is designed to solicit opinions or best-practices on a particular topic, with the goal of reaching community consensus.
80
questions
33
votes
2
answers
1k
views
What is Hardware?
Not hardware, but Hardware.
We've half-defined our scope, thanks to Robert. The other half of defining our scope is an issue that's been sitting around since Day 1, and one that I've seen plenty of ...
- 2,291
17
votes
1
answer
1k
views
What is required for a question to be 'high quality'?
This is the question version of What is required for an answer to be 'high quality'?
(It is modeled off of What is required for a question to contain "enough information"? from Software ...
AndyMod
- 3,368
12
votes
1
answer
291
views
What is required for an answer to be 'high quality'?
Seeing +15/-0 consensus on Should we have SR-style quality guidelines for questions and answers?, I would say it's time to figure out what we require in answers.
What is required for an answer to be '...
- 2,244
9
votes
5
answers
305
views
Do we still want general advice questions?
Prompted by this question.
A long time ago, we decided that "what should I consider"/general advice-type questions are allowed. We had at least one of these questions, which seemed to be pretty well-...
- 2,291
22
votes
7
answers
443
views
What type of hardware is allowed?
I have asked this question: Standing desk with ability to raise/lower?
It is receiving a few close votes for "not about computing hardware."
A key thing this site will need to determine is what the ...
- 1,509
16
votes
5
answers
330
views
Are "What should I consider when buying" questions allowed? [duplicate]
Note that this discussion is no longer current. We revisited this topic later in the life of this site.
Please see Do we still want general advice questions? and post your thoughts there.
Should we ...
- 2,244
15
votes
2
answers
355
views
Is a scope of "product recommendations" + "pre-purchase inquiries" agreeable?
The Community Team is nearing the private beta evaluations to decide whether to move this site forward, but I've hit a few snags expressing purpose and the scope of this site.
I am confident we are on ...
- 196
12
votes
5
answers
763
views
What can we do about technical support questions?
Recently, I posted an answer here on meta. In it, I realise that we have a problem with technical support questions - essentially, going on half of our questions are closed, and going on half of those ...
- 2,291
5
votes
4
answers
240
views
Should this site be called "Hardware Search"?
I'm just thinking out loud here.
Folks often ask me where they should ask a question about their stuff, and when they start focusing in on "Hardware Recommendations", the conversation ...
- 196
8
votes
6
answers
325
views
How to handle questions with too few requirements?
After seeing a few questions listing very few requirements, I realize we never actually discussed what to do if there is a low-quality question in terms of soliciting an overly-broad product ...
- 2,179
18
votes
3
answers
171
views
Should we have SR-style quality guidelines for questions and answers?
This site is different than most - we're an opinion based site. This topic is the reason 'shopping recommendations' were banned on Stack Overflow. If we don't want to become a spam center, I think we ...
- 2,244
10
votes
1
answer
131
views
Should we have a close reason for technical support questions?
We've gotten several questions that have been technical support type questions:
https://hardwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/695/cant-be-established-connection-with-internet-whats-up
https://...
AndyMod
- 3,368
6
votes
3
answers
75
views
Should we delete things that don't match our criteria?
It was proposed, then it was implemented for questions and answers. We have quality guidelines for questions and answers; now, the question is how we enforce them.
Now that this site has some ...
- 2,291
6
votes
3
answers
153
views
Should we edit the sidebar text on the ask page?
As you may have seen, we have an issue with technical support questions.
One of the various solutions that has been discussed (proposed in chat and in a meta answer by Andy) is to edit the text in the ...
- 2,291
16
votes
1
answer
336
views
Why is this community not allowed to decide its scope?
The general rule I've seen around Stack Exchange is that a community is sovereign in deciding its scope¹, as long as it makes a modicum of sense. Stack Exchange employees may enforce quality ...
7
votes
2
answers
93
views
Should we have a custom 'too broad' off-topic reason?
In Robert Cartaino's answer here, he mentions this text:
Closed as a broad recommendation or poll
"Hardware Recommendations" is a community-run website to help participants complete an ...
- 2,244
7
votes
2
answers
119
views
Are build requests on-topic?
Are questions like
"I want to build a gaming computer that does a b c and also does x y z for less than $___"?
on topic here? Or do they have to be recommendations about an already existing list ...
- 213
6
votes
0
answers
192
views
The moderator election has been extended until October 18, 2022 – please check your ballots to ensure your selections have been saved!
As some of you may know, we recently identified a bug affecting moderator elections – and fixed it. This bug was preventing some users' election ballots (i.e. selections) from being saved in a very ...
- 101
5
votes
3
answers
127
views
Let's explain what "technical support" means and how to properly fix the question to be on topic
I've proposed creating a new faq question covering what we consider "technical support". The idea is that we can use this as further guidance to users on what not to ask and how their technical ...
AndyMod
- 3,368
-2
votes
3
answers
97
views
Add specific close reason for SuperUser content
Discussion here relates to questions being on topic on SuperUser, and therefore not here.
I suggest adding the following as a custom close reason:
"Hardware Recommendations" was created for ...
- 1,509
13
votes
3
answers
101
views
Pricing as a requirement
How do we handle pricing requirements stated in questions?
Do we:
Consider them hard limits?
Expect proof of sale-price in all answers?
One of the problems is that pricing differs all over the ...
- 237
12
votes
3
answers
94
views
Are answers recommending unreleased, unannounced hardware allowed?
Prompted by this answer to What's a good life-proof Android phone?:
The upcoming Moto X Force is the phone that sound like the perfect fit(its not revealed or released yet!)
Watch out! These are just ...
- 2,244
11
votes
2
answers
82
views
Are DIY hardware recommendations allowed?
Now, I have been interested in the maker and hacker community for a long time. I have learned about the Arduino and Raspberry Pi, etc. Are recommendation questions about such DIY hardware platforms ...
- 208
10
votes
2
answers
108
views
Should we define "pre-purchase" vs "technical support"?
After a recent discussion about technical support questions, I went through some of our recent closures to gather more data. I return with a question for the community:
How do we tell the difference ...
AndyMod
- 3,368
10
votes
8
answers
220
views
Community Promotion Ads - Let's advertise this site!
There are ads that have already reached the 6-vote threshold and have been submitted to other sites. The following are the relevant ads that have been submitted:
Arqade
Game Dev
Graphic Design
...
- 904
10
votes
1
answer
109
views
Are appliance-related questions on-topic?
I think someone asked this on the commitment phrase, but I do not remember the responses.
Are we going to allow questions related to appliances?
An example could it be:
Which washer/dryer allows ...
- 203
8
votes
3
answers
98
views
Should we allow software alternatives to hardware requests to be "valid" answers?
Do we allow alternatives to the requested hardware to remain as valid answers? I believe we allow a wide variety of hardware to be an "answer". Not all of the hardware can fulfill all requirements, ...
AndyMod
- 3,368
7
votes
1
answer
165
views
Which tags need to be cleaned up?
Which tags need to be cleaned up by a user with elevated editing or tag privileges?
Instead of posting a new answer per tag, feel free to just edit the CW answer.
- 422
7
votes
3
answers
75
views
Are questions related to third party hosting requirements on topic?
I've thrown up a question related to a dedicated server that will be hosted (most likely) by a third party. The idea behind this question is to upgrade from a VPS to another piece of hardware. Is a ...
AndyMod
- 3,368
7
votes
1
answer
121
views
Can/should we have a question interstitial for extra guidance?
On new private beta sites, you can't ask a question without first going through an interstitial screen that gives you advice on how to ask during the private beta.
I recently did a micro-study into ...
- 2,291
6
votes
2
answers
270
views
Anyone else getting frustrated with what is consider on topic at the Hardware Recommendations Stack Exchange?
Question:
Anyone else getting frustrated with what is consider on topic at the Hardware Recommendations Stack Exchange?
My Opinion:
Its being over moderated. I see questions being placed on hold ...
user3725
6
votes
1
answer
84
views
Are batteries on-topic?
https://hardwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/2395/what-type-of-battery-should-i-get
is currently closed for being tech support. It has recently been edited to make it less tech support, but still ...
- 2,291
4
votes
3
answers
81
views
Are questions on defining requirements on-topic? [duplicate]
Should a question like this be closed?
What should I look for besides pixel density/count when choosing a smartphone with a good camera?
It was closed because the user didn't list definitive ...
- 1,130
4
votes
2
answers
57
views
Merge [hdd] into [hard-disk]
I noticed my first question which I had tagged hard-disk got retagged as hdd. I prefer the full name rather than the abbreviation. But most of all, I think one of those two tags should definitely be a ...
- 719
17
votes
4
answers
103
views
How are we going to handle questions / answers becoming outdated?
This was brought up on Area 51, but I don't think it was sufficiently addressed.
Taking into consideration the following:
The primary goal of a Stack Exchange site is not to simply provide an answer ...
- 461
11
votes
2
answers
64
views
Proposal: Require computer specs to be posted in the question instead of behind a link
I'd like to propose a quality guideline to help prevent confusion in the future.
Proposal
Users posting information about their computer need to have the components listed in the question itself not ...
AndyMod
- 3,368
10
votes
1
answer
133
views
Are DIY Recommendation answers appropriate?
I've seen a few answers that propose the OP gets their hands dirty and build a thing to solve their problem. I can't seem to find the others right now, but a recent answer is this:
What I'm ...
AndyMod
- 3,368
9
votes
2
answers
47
views
How should disclosure work if we're answering based on hardware for review?
Well, while I've not been that lucky yet, I'd be pretty happy to try out hardware and review it in various places, primarily my blog. I do that already with hardware I buy. There's two possible ...
- 3,731
9
votes
3
answers
104
views
How would you rate HR at this moment?
How would you rate HR at this moment?
Is the community active enough?
What problems may we encounter in the long run?
What do you especially like/dislike about this site?
- 1,500
9
votes
0
answers
321
views
Let's clean up some broken windows - A proposal for dealing with tech support questions
We've had previous discussions about technical support questions we recieve. Repeatedly. There have been concerns about how many [on hold] or [closed] questions that this places on the main page.
...
AndyMod
- 3,368
9
votes
4
answers
106
views
Which other Stack Exchange sites have a userbase that would be interested in our site?
Now that we've reached Public Beta, part of our job is getting the word about Hardware Recommendations out. One way to do that is via Community Ads. These ads are voted upon by the Stack Exchange ...
AndyMod
- 3,368
8
votes
1
answer
85
views
Help! What's on-topic here?
When people arrive at our site, they'll be directed to /help/on-topic for guidance about what's on-topic here. Said page currently contains basically nothing useful; I can tell you that without even ...
- 2,291
8
votes
1
answer
66
views
Are questions asking how well a piece of hardware does X accepted?
Triggered by How many players would this VPS be able to take?: Are questions that essentially ask this accepted?
I am looking at x hardware ([specs]), and I'd like to know how well it does ([...
- 2,244
7
votes
1
answer
83
views
Laser cutters on topic?
I'm likely going to be in the market for a laser cutter with significant ability to be controlled from my computer (my computer capability will limit what I can do with it). It'll definitely have a ...
- 1,509
7
votes
2
answers
59
views
Differences from SuperUser
Unfortunately a lot of questions here are about Hardware support as well as shopping. These questions belong on SuperUser. How do we prevent users from asking questions? How can we as a whole improve ...
- 353
7
votes
3
answers
134
views
How do we encourage new users to stay on topic?
11 of the last 12 questions are on hold for being off topic.
What can we do to encourage users to stay on topic?
Is there any indication that the authors of these off topic questions are returning ...
AndyMod
- 3,368
7
votes
1
answer
109
views
Should we have a 'blatantly off-topic' custom close reason?
We got a custom close reason for unclear questions - yay!
However, when we got this it deactivated the 'standard' blatantly off-topic reason, thereby making us have to use custom comments for ...
- 2,244
7
votes
2
answers
79
views
How can we detect (and deal with) spam?
The premise of Hardware Recommendations is that Person A is looking for one or more product(s) that will satisfy certain criteria or complete a certain task. Persons B, C, D, etc. may write answers ...
- 541
6
votes
2
answers
51
views
Should we encourage users not to leave answers as comments?
I just joined this site today. After looking through the first page of questions, I see that many of the questions are answered, but just as a comment (see end of post for list). I understand that ...
- 528
6
votes
3
answers
111
views
Are "case" questions off-topic?
The case tag has a strange wiki.
For questions about protective cases for hardware. May be off-topic.
Am I missing something? We have 10 questions tagged case and a lot of them are very high ...
- 860